Car of the Year 2006: Cadillac STS-V

  • The STS-V at Rudd Vineyards & Winery.
  • “This car exhibits tight handling for a Cadillac. Keep trying, GM. You’re almost there.” —Gary Verboon
  • Photo courtesy of General Motors
    “It’s like Jack Nicholson as the Joker in Batman: wild-eyed and crazy, but not a lot of refinement.” —Todd Thomson Photo courtesy of General Motors
  • Photo courtesy of General Motors
    “This car is not bad at all; it’s just not good enough.” —Scott Kriens Photo courtesy of General Motors
  • Photo courtesy of General Motors
  • Photo courtesy of General Motors
<< Back to Robb Report, February 2006
  • Gregory Anderson

Patterned after m-wearing BMWs and AMG-badged Mercedes-Benz cars, V-Series Cadillacs pack more performance than the average Caddy.

In building the STS-V, the hot rod version of its stately STS sedan, Cadillac affixed a supercharger to its Northstar V-8, creating the marque’s most powerful engine ever. Fitted neatly under the STS-V’s bulging hood, this V-8 breathes with 10 to 12 pounds of boost, which contributes to its total output of 469 hp and 439 ft lbs of torque. Doling all that motivation to the 19-inch rear wheels is a 6-speed Hydra-Matic automatic transmission that shifts itself from zero to 60 mph in less than five seconds.

While the engine alone might be enough to impress under different circumstances, at the Car of the Year event, 469 hp is just the price of admission for a sports sedan. The Mercedes CLS55 AMG offers the same output, and the BMW M5 raises the bar with a 500 hp V-10 motor. Our alphabetical road-testing rotation had drivers hopping out of the M5 and into the STS-V, making for a salient sedan comparison.

Most of our judges had hoped their homeland car would fare better against one of Bavaria’s best. “As an American, I wanted the Cadillac to be good,” said Bob Morris. “But as a driver, I have to say that it is not.” Garen Staglin echoed that sentiment: “The STS-V is not in the same league as the M5.” It is, however, in the same price range, which some found surprising. “If the STS-V cost $48,000, it would be a player,” said Dan D’Agostino. The base STS sedan, it should be noted, does start at less than $42,000.

Of our trio of performance sedans, the Mercedes garnered kudos for its unique design, but the appearances of the BMW and the Cadillac failed to impress. William Weidner referred to the Caddy’s “Cubist exterior design” as something that only an art lover could appreciate. The interior fared even worse, being described as “tacky” by one judge.

But all was not lost. Many of the judges were encouraged by Cadillac’s effort; Bill Harlan noted that the STS-V is “easy and bulletproof to drive.” Still, the consensus seemed to be that General Motors has a ways to go before its top-of-the-line sports sedan catches up with the Germans’. As Scott Kriens said, “This car is not bad at all; it’s just not good enough.”

 

SPECIFICATIONS

ENGINE 4.4-liter supercharged V-8
POWER 469 hp at 6,400 rpm
TORQUE 439 ft lbs at 3,900 rpm
ZERO-TO-60 4.6 seconds
TOP SPEED 163 mph (governed)
TRANSMISSION 6-speed automatic with manual gear selection   
WHEELBASE 116.4 inches
CURB WEIGHT 4,295 pounds
BASE PRICE $77,000

From Around the Web...
Robb Report's Car of the Year contest ended in a tie between the Lamborghini Huracán Spyder and the Porsche 911 Turbo S.
The results mark a first in the annual event’s history and bode well for the industry…
More than 150 Robb Report readers convened in Napa Valley to judge 13 extraordinary automobiles…
Watch video profiles of each of the Car of the Year 2017 contenders...
Robb Report Car of the Year 2017
During Robb Report’s annual competition to determine which sport or luxury car best deserves to be...
The Giulia Quadrifoglio, the high-performance variant of Alfa Romeo’s new sedan, went on sale in December with a starting price of $72,000.
The top-of-the-line sedan is powered by a biturbo V-6 that churns out more than 500 hp…
The 2018 Porsche 911 GT3
Next year, the model comes with a new engine, a revised chassis, and plenty of performance…
The 2017 Ruf CTR at the 87th Geneva International Motor Show.
With 700 hp and a top speed of 223 mph, this two-door tears it up…
If the DB11 were less of a looker, it might earn more attention for being the Best-performing, best-handling Aston Martin yet
The company’s first all-new car in 13 years was worth the wait…
The Lexus LC 500 will arrive at U.S. dealerships this spring sporting a bold new look for the brand…
The Lamborghini Aventador S
The head of Lamborghini for the Americas talks about why the car and company are cruising…