Car of the Year 2009: No. 12: Smart ForTwo

  • Paul Dean and Marco R. della Cava

Boxcar Willies
The Mercedes-developed Smart is cute, can be parked sideways in Paris (but not in Beverly Hills), and costs about the same as (and gets better gas mileage than) a Volkswagen Beetle. And for making pizza deliveries, solo runs to the store, or commutes between your midtown loft and downtown office, this vehicle has few equals. So what’s not to like? Well, as some judges noticed, the Smart is as tall as it is wide, and such proportions serve only to salve the conscience of an anticongestion crusader. This cube wobbles at speed and feels as though it will tip over when taking corners. The interior, although quite roomy for two people in light clothing, is early Home Depot, and the 5-speed automated manual transmission heaves through every shift. The Smart’s only salvation may well be its potential conversion to an electric engine. —Paul Dean

 

Brains But No Brawn
Smart cars are a familiar sight to anyone who has ventured to Europe in the past 10 years, and now they are starting to appear in some major U.S. cities. It is no wonder why: The cars get an appealing 41 mpg on the highway, and you can squeeze them into the smallest of parking spaces. However, as the name suggests, the Smart Fortwo really is just for two people, with some luggage or groceries stowed in the back. The ride is good but not inspiring, even in this Brabus-tweaked edition, which has a sports suspension and a sweeter exhaust but few other upgrades. The Smart car is one of many great options for consuming less gasoline, and it will turn heads for its quirkiness, but you would have much more fun driving a fuel-sipping Mini Cooper S, forfour. —Marco R. della Cava

SPECIFICATIONS:

Configuration Rear-engine, rear-wheel-drive cabriolet
Engine 1-liter, 3-cylinder
Transmission 5-speed automated manual
Power 70 hp at 5,800 rpm
Torque 68 ft lbs at 4,500 rpm
Zero to 60 12.8 seconds
Top Speed 90 mph
Base Price $21,635
Price as Tested $22,155
Robb Report Rating 66
Smart USA, www.smartusa.com

Read Next Article >>
Photo by Scott Williamson/ www.photodesignstudios.com; Automobile courtesy Boulevard Motorcar Company
1948 Delahaye 135M Figoni et Falaschi Narval Cabriolet. The Delahaye Narval, the fantastic...
The new bike was put through its paces during a ride around California’s Salton Sea...
When the fourth-annual Austrian Alpine Rally set off from the starting line in Vienna on the...
Photo by UWE@FISCHER
The new “sport activity coupe,” as BMW calls it, drives with a nimbleness that defies its size…
Photo by Richard Prince
Chevy’s new supercar aims to redefine the American muscle car…
Darin Schnabel/RM Auctions
Mercedes-Benz 300 SLc are soaring at auction...
The nearly 1,000 cc motorcycles draw inspiration from Yamaha’s seven-figure MotoGP race bike…
In both design and performance, the new S-Class Coupes branch out from Mercedes’s historically...
The sedan is set to compete with the BMW 3 Series, Mercedes-Benz C-Class, and Audi A3…
Photo by Daylight Studio Snc
A century of quintessentially Italian carmaking and motorsports…