Car of the Year: No. 7 (Tie): Jaguar XKR Convertible

<< Back to Robb Report, February 2007
  • Paul Dean

Some see Jaguar’s latest as a lovely luxury grand tourer that is to the British manner born, with all of its breeding and provenance firmly intact. However, several of our judges equated the XKR with a nipped-and-tucked former starlet: It is an attractive car, but it is showing its years. The car seems to lack immediacy, others said, and its mechanicals do not provide enough boot.

 

The XKR’s designer is Ian Callum, creator of Aston Martin’s DB7 and devotee of the Ghia way of shaping cars. He plucked from the past when fashioning this new Jaguar line, which began with the 2006 XK and now features the higher-performing and supercharged XKR coupe and convertible. His announced aim was to merge the classicism of previous XKs with contemporary lines and an all-aluminum build. His intention was to update and not obliterate the ovoid front end, flared headlights, and other styling elements of the adored E-Types. 

Some judges understood Callum’s objective and applauded the results. “The car is sexy,” said Steve Bond. “It’s an entry-level Aston Martin.”

Added Bill Harlan, “It exceeded my expectations. For approximately the same price as the Cadillac [XLR-V] it represents twice the value.”

However, Jamie May was among those who disagreed with such positive reviews. “It was too smooth, and I couldn’t feel the torque,” he said. “It felt as though I were driving a Ford. The Cadillac was much nicer.” 

So went the seesaw, and when all ayes and nays were tallied, the XKR finished in the middle of our pack. On paper and in the flesh, the XKR—the R denoting the heavy tuning that distinguishes this car from the lighter XK series—remains as impressive as any in its class, and certainly more threatening to its 2+2 competition from Germany than any previous Jag. The base XK still comes with a 300 hp V-8 from the previous generation, and the XKR has been given the same 4.2-liter engine, but it has been tweaked and bolted to an Eaton supercharger, a combination that produces 420 hp. A stiffer suspension, larger wheels, aluminum gills, wire mesh inserts in the grille, and a chin intake further estrange the XKR from the XK.

On the road, the XKR fulfills its design purpose. It was not built to be a big and raucous sports car; it is supposed to move with much grace, huge pace, and an enticing distinction that always has been associated with Jaguar. These virtues were enough to prompt Mike Yager to switch his allegiance at the polls. “The car I most wanted to drive was the BMW [M6],” he said. “The car I least wanted to drive was the Jag. I love the Jag, and I didn’t like the BMW. The Jaguar was more fun than the BMW.”

SPECIFICATIONS:

ENGINE: 4.2-liter, supercharged V-8
TRANSMISSION: 6-speed automatic
with  paddle shifting
POWER: 420 hp at 6,000 rpm
TORQUE: 413 ft lbs at 4,000 rpm
CURB WEIGHT: 3,924 pounds
LENGTH: 188.6 inches
ZERO-TO-60: 5 seconds
TOP SPEED: 155 mph (limited)
BASE PRICE: $92,500  

From Around the Web...
Robb Report's Car of the Year contest ended in a tie between the Lamborghini Huracán Spyder and the Porsche 911 Turbo S.
The results mark a first in the annual event’s history and bode well for the industry…
Robb Report Car of the Year 2017
During Robb Report’s annual competition to determine which sport or luxury car best deserves to be...
More than 150 Robb Report readers convened in Napa Valley to judge 13 extraordinary automobiles…
Watch video profiles of each of the Car of the Year 2017 contenders...
The Giulia Quadrifoglio, the high-performance variant of Alfa Romeo’s new sedan, went on sale in December with a starting price of $72,000.
The top-of-the-line sedan is powered by a biturbo V-6 that churns out more than 500 hp…
The 2018 Porsche 911 GT3
Next year, the model comes with a new engine, a revised chassis, and plenty of performance…
The 2017 Ruf CTR at the 87th Geneva International Motor Show.
With 700 hp and a top speed of 223 mph, this two-door tears it up…
If the DB11 were less of a looker, it might earn more attention for being the Best-performing, best-handling Aston Martin yet
The company’s first all-new car in 13 years was worth the wait…
The Lexus LC 500 will arrive at U.S. dealerships this spring sporting a bold new look for the brand…
The Lamborghini Aventador S
The head of Lamborghini for the Americas talks about why the car and company are cruising…