Robb Report Car of the Year 2008: No. 10 Mercedes-Benz SLR McClaren Roadster

  • Gregory Anderson, Paul Dean and Marco R. della Cava

Great Expectations.
It is built by Mercedes, one of the world’s oldest and finest carmakers. Its performance is burnished by McLaren, a name that has ruled F/1 racing longer than Henry VIII ran England. And it is based on the highly envied SLR, a car renowned for more than a half century for its speed, athleticism, comfort, and quiet ride. So maybe we anticipated too much from this racecar in roadster clothing. Or maybe the car’s $500,000 price raised our expectations. Either way, the Roadster revealed itself as less of a car to drive than an adversary to battle. The McLaren earns its image as an Anglo-German ultra supercar, but with 617 hp and almost as many foot-pounds of torque going to the rear wheels, it has a habit of wandering when accelerating. Some drivers will consider it the ultimate driving machine, one with exotic looks, grand power, and fierce and irascible behavior. However you feel about this car, don’t turn your back on it. —Paul Dean

Shark and Awe
Great whites and Mercedes supercars have more than just gills in common. Like the shark, the SLR McLaren Roadster has an appetite for human appendages, or so senior correspondent Paul Dean learned. "The door doesn’t close all the way unless you slam it," Dean explained to one of our judges, just before that guest slammed the door on two of Dean’s fingers and nearly severed them. The incident prompted one to wonder why a half-million-dollar car does not have electronic door closers, as many of Mercedes-Benz’s lesser models do. The roof is only semiautomatic, requiring muscle to raise or lower, and there is no tonneau to cover the exposed mechanical bits and pieces. Sure, it is faster than schnell, but driven around town, or just about anywhere other than on the autobahn, the McLaren Roadster seems like a shark in a fishbowl. —Gregory Anderson

High-Priced Imperfections
The Roadster is fast and impossible to ignore, a Batmobile for the billionaire. But too much about the car gives pause, especially if you believe a $500,000 vehicle should inspire nothing but accolades. The brakes require a hammering action to bring the car down from speed, the gullwing doors render the car difficult to enter, and when the top stows, you see all of its mechanical components. —Marco R. della Cava

Mercedes-Benz, www.mbusa.com

LAYOUT
Front-mid-engine, rear-wheel drive
ENGINE
5.4-liter supercharged V-8
TRANSMISSION
5-speed automatic
POWER
617 hp, 575 ft lbs
ZERO-TO-60
3.8 seconds
TOP SPEED
206 mph

BASE PRICE: $500,750
PRICE AS TESTED: $512,250
ROBB REPORT RATING: 63.1

Read Next Article >>
The lots include Carroll Shelby’s personal Shelby Cobra 427 Super Snake, which previously fetched $...
The new concept suggests that Bentley is gunning for the Rolls-Royce Phantom Drophead Coupé…
Patrick Gosling
The McLaren GTR Driver Program puts P1 GTR owners on the track with a dedicated race team…
Daimler AG - Global Communications Mercedes-Benz Cars
Robb Report runs the all-new sports car through its paces at the Laguna Seca raceway…
Photo by Scott Williamson/ www.photodesignstudios.com; Automobile courtesy Boulevard Motorcar Company
1948 Delahaye 135M Figoni et Falaschi Narval Cabriolet. The Delahaye Narval, the fantastic...
The new bike was put through its paces during a ride around California’s Salton Sea...
When the fourth-annual Austrian Alpine Rally set off from the starting line in Vienna on the...
Photo by UWE@FISCHER
The new “sport activity coupe,” as BMW calls it, drives with a nimbleness that defies its size…
Photo by Richard Prince
Chevy’s new supercar aims to redefine the American muscle car…
Darin Schnabel/RM Auctions
Mercedes-Benz 300 SLc are soaring at auction...