An Expert’s Advice on Collecting Everything, Including Real Estate

  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
    In the gallery of Bruno’s Tuxedo Park home, a stone table bought online displays a 1970s sculpture found at an antiques mall. Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
    Michael Bruno has many collections, but his greatest passion is real estate. Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
    Bruno’s main house in Tuxedo Park, N.Y., designed by John Russell Pope in 1900 Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
    The back of the house, overlooking a lake Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
    The 1901 Loomis Laboratory Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
    The Tuxedo Park casino Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
    The Tuxedo Park boathouse Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • His large collection of animal-motif items includes a pair of plaster camel trophies, monkey figurines, and a nearly 5-foot-tall black rooster. The animals “uplift the rooms, make them fun,” he says.
  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
    Bruno’s office contains more animal-motif pieces, including a pair of resin tusks, along with carved wooden mushroom sculptures and other objects with presence and weight. Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Carin Katt
    Limited-edition contemporary furnishings, such as Marc Newson’s Lockheed Lounge, are on the upswing Photo by Carin Katt
  • Midcentury modern pieces, such as this Charles Eames storage unit, have finally peaked
  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Adrian Gusa
  • Photo by Deena Feinberg
  • Photo by Carin Katt
  • Barbara King

Originally published in the October 2015 issue of Robb Report Collection as “First Buy What You Love

Michael Bruno, the founder of 1stdibs, has a passionate approach to the art of collecting. 

Michael Bruno has always had an eye for great design and a knack for thinking big. His love of architecture and grand old houses led him to obtain a real estate license when he was 19, and after a lucrative career as a broker for Sotheby’s, he moved to Paris. One day he was shopping for antiques at the Marché aux Puces when he was struck with an ingenious idea: Why not put the famed flea market online, and make all these amazing finds available to the world? It would be a first, a virtual marketplace for high-end, one-of-a-kind items.

In 2001, Bruno turned his pioneering vision into a reality when he founded 1stdibs. Over the next decade, the site would expand its reach worldwide and revolutionize the way luxury goods are bought and sold. By 2014, it had logged more than $1 billion in transactions and become the premier online source for antiques, fine art, furniture, estate jewelry, and vintage couture—“a place,” as Bruno has described it, “where collections are born.” 

Naturally, Bruno is also an enthusiastic collector—of antique and vintage furnishings, as well as noteworthy real estate. We spoke with him about the art of assembling a great collection, shopping in the digital age, and trends in luxury buying. Now 51, he has relinquished his role as CEO of 1stdibs to focus on a new project, an app called Housepad whose functions include managing all that stuff collectors tend to accumulate. 

Are there risks in buying collectibles online?
You have to make sure you read the fine print, so that you know the condition of the piece, whether there’s a no-return policy, and what the dimensions are. Sometimes people just look at the image and go for it. I’ve done that myself. I was buying an antique dining table and chairs­—from two different dealers­—that I just knew would be so perfect together. But I didn’t bother to check the actual size of the chairs; I thought dining chairs were dining chairs. And you know what arrived? Sweet little children’s chairs!

Any other advice for collectors? 
Keep an open mind—that’s an essential aspect of collecting. Here’s an example of that. I was sure I wanted a round center table—dark wood, single pedestal—for the gallery in my main house. So I started searching the site and there were quite a few good choices. But then I saw this irregular, light-colored limestone table and I thought, Whoa! Wait! That’s much more striking. If you see something and think whoa—pay attention. Don’t ignore that instant gut reaction. I would add this, too: If you see something you love and it’s special, don’t hesitate to buy it. Great things do sell fast and you may never see it again. I happened upon a ’20s display cabinet embellished with fish motifs that I fell in love with, and when I heard the price—$18,000—my jaw dropped. But I said to myself, when will I ever see that again? And you know what? It’s one of the things I own that will be going out after I do.  

Is going with your gut the best way to build a collection? 
It is for me. I buy what I love, and it doesn’t have to be the best of anything. It just has to appeal to me. I feel a collection should unfold, should be a natural, organic process rather than a deliberate one. I’m a passion collector. But there’s another type, and that’s the studied collector who approaches acquisitions like stocks—investments that will appreciate in time. Studied collectors have a more precise, strict point of view. They want a specific thing and they’re only going to collect the best examples of someone’s work. I wouldn’t find that nearly as much fun as collecting out of pure passion, but I’m sure it’s far more rewarding financially.

What is your greatest collecting passion? 
I’m a real estate junkie, an incurable collector of property. And that’s a tricky thing to collect, because you can only have so many at one time. 

I’m particularly drawn to old houses that need renovation. When I was in my early 20s, I was working as a real estate broker in La Jolla [Calif.], and I bought a 1920s Mediterranean-style villa by William Templeton Johnson that was in danger of being torn down. That fired up my passion for restoration and preservation. If I have a chance to buy a historic property by a notable architect in a prime location, then I sort of go into studied-collector mode because I know I’ve really got something. 

Tell us about your real estate portfolio.
At the moment I have two 14,000-square-foot brick houses in New York. One is in Southampton, and it isn’t old but it has a glorious 40-acre meadow view. The other is in Tuxedo Park, a gated enclave about an hour from Manhattan that’s known for its Gilded Age mansions. The main house was designed in 1900 by John Russell Pope. It sits on 20 acres overlooking the lake, and there’s a guesthouse and a boathouse as well. Behind the property is a 55-acre garden—well, a park, really—that I just bought, designed by the Central Park landscape architect, Frederick Law Olmsted. Paths, brooks, a waterfall, just gorgeous. And I own three other buildings in Tuxedo Park. I recently bought the Loomis Laboratory, a spectacular 1901 stone castle that originally belonged to Spencer Trask, the financier who founded Yaddo, the artists’ retreat in Saratoga Springs. Trask then sold it in the ’20s to Alfred Lee Loomis, a Wall Street tycoon with an interest in science who turned it into a private lab. It’s a dream—I haven’t been so excited about a piece of real estate in a long time. I’m going to convert the entry, living room, and gallery into one big space and use it as an office. I also have two old commercial buildings in the village, and I’ve made an offer on another, a James Brown Lord carriage house that I want so badly, I can hardly stand it.

(Continues on next page...)

From Around the Web...
Sotheby’s three-part sale will feature more than 350 pieces of art owned by the masterful musician…
Julien’s Auctions will present more than 700 lots from legendary musicians throughout the two-day...
Painted by the Dutch artist in 1977, the piece set an auction record when it was previously sold…
The biggest collection of its kind to cross the block in 15 years spans the history of the game…
To honor the show’s semicentennial, we present a phaser rifle, Kirk’s captain’s chair, and more…
The collection of 350 drawing tools is almost as colorful as the personality that inspired them…
The backless, rhinestone-covered evening gown will be auctioned in Los Angeles…
Photography by Jean-François Jaussaud
Art dealer Victor Gastou furnishes a 19th-century property with modern decorative art…
Manhattan’s new Twenty First gallery shines a spotlight on artist Emmanuel Babled…
Photo by Mike Bruce
London’s Louis Guinness Gallery will offer notable necklaces by Alexander Calder…