BEST of the BEST 2015: Masseto 2011 Toscana

A super Tuscan by any name.

Although wine enthusiasts drink Super Tuscans with, well, great enthusiasm, not all of them can define precisely what one is. Coined in the 1970s, the term denotes Indicazione geografica tipica wines—or typical regional wines—that fall outside of the parameters of Denominazione di origine controllata e garantita labeling regulations. The latter guidelines require that a wine be produced in a specific region and in compliance with specific standards, which stipulate the varietals used and the aging regimen. Some vintners in Tuscany’s best-known winemaking region, Chianti, frustrated by these often arcane rules, began to make table wines that enabled them to bypass regulators. Ironically, the wineries’ common goal in eschewing these quality controls was to make better wine. One of the early examples was Tigna­nello 1971, a blend of Sangiovese and Cabernet Sauvignon created by Piero Antinori that hit the market in 1978—but the very first was Sassicaia, which Antinori’s uncle, Mario Incisa della Rocchetta, inaugurated with the release of the 1968 vintage.

Sassicaia not only shifted the figurative landscape of Italian winemaking, but also transformed the literal countryside surrounding the small town of Bolgheri on the Tuscan coast, where Incisa della Rocchetta’s estate of Tenuta San Guido was located. The success of this blend of Caber­net Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc, modeled on the wines of Graves, attracted other aspirants to the area. Among them was Antinori’s brother, Lodovico, who, determined to make a wine of his own, purchased an olive grove adjacent to Tenuta San Guido. As fond of California wines as his uncle Mario was of those from Bordeaux, Lodovico conscripted the famed Napa Valley oenologist André Tchelistcheff to advise him in planting Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, and Petit Verdot on his property, which he christened Tenuta dell’Ornellaia. The result of this collaboration, the 1985 vintage of Ornellaia, combined the ripeness of California with the structured minerality of Graves, and soon Lodovico’s estate became as famous as its neighbor.

Yet Tchelistcheff’s most important contribution to Tenuta dell’Ornellaia—and the history of the Super Tuscan—may be his recognition that a certain hill of densely packed gray clay, rock, and sand on the estate would make an ideal place to plant Merlot. This vineyard, named Masseto—a reference to its rocky composition—proved the astuteness of the oenologist’s observation, and the wines that come from this place now represent some of the finest and most expensive examples of the Super Tuscan in existence.

The 2011 Masseto ($625) sets a new high point for this single-vineyard, single-varietal red. Its gorgeously dark purple hue presages deep, intoxicating scents and flavors of boysenberry, black raspberry, strawberry, dark chocolate, dried fig, and thyme. The texture is so voluptuous that one almost hesitates to swallow, and the finish lingers lusciously. Originally called Merlot di Ornellaia and, later, Tenuta dell’Ornellaia Masseto, this most superb of Super Tuscans is now simply called Masseto—and we can offer no word of higher praise.

Masseto, www.masseto.com

Purchase the June 2015 issue to see all of this year's Best of the Best selections. >>
See more 2015 Best of the Best FREE PREVIEWS. >>

From Around the Web...
Ask a bartender for a Hemingway and you’ll get a daiquiri with grapefruit juice and maraschino...
Wines from Trump Winery and Clinton Vineyards compete in a Robb Report taste test…
From rum to craft beer, these luxury destinations are the only place you can sip
Only 2,333 bottles will be released of the new expression combining three vintages of 100-percent...
With similar soil to Cuba, Honduras produces some of the world’s finest cigars…
Sommelier Erik Johnson has been on an enviable spree. Restocking the wine cellar of the French...
The four-sided box-pressed Nicaraguan puro concentrates the flavor in every puff…
These lesser-known bottles from Italy’s most innovative winemaker will surprise you…
Generations of Cognac expertise went into this extravagant tribute to Hennessy’s history…
If you love fine Cognac and rare cigars, join us for a connoisseur’s tour…