Thirsty Collectors Are on the Hunt for Long-Lost Libations

  • Photo by Francesco Tonelli
    Leo Robitschek (center) of NoMad Bar in New York City pours vintage spirits neat and in cocktails such as a $198 Vieux Carré made with L'Artisan No. 50. Photo by Francesco Tonelli
  • Photo by Francesco Tonelli
    NoMad Bar in New York City. Photo by Francesco Tonelli
  • Photo by Marvin Shaouni
    Vintage Pimm's is among the "dusty bottles" at the Oakland Art Novelty Co. in Michigan. Photo by Marvin Shaouni
  • This Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Macallan 33 Year Old single malt fetched $1,960 at a Zachys auction earlier this year.
  • Photo by Allen Lin
    At Vestry, a private club above Tom Bergin's in Los Angeles, the bar is stocked with rarities such as the Black Maple Hill collection. Photo by Allen Lin
  • At Vestry, a private club above Tom Bergin's in Los Angeles, the bar is stocked with rarities such as the Black Maple Hill collection.
  • Photo by Ben Fisher
    Hedonism Wines, an exclusive shop in London's Mayfair district, also stocks a tremendous array of rare spirits. Photo by Ben Fisher
  • Hedonism Wines, an exclusive shop in London's Mayfair district, also stocks a tremendous array of rare spirits.
  • Hedonism Wines, an exclusive shop in London's Mayfair district, also stocks a tremendous array of rare spirits, including a bottle of Duffy's Pure Malt Whiskey dating from the 1890s. The price: $18,400.
  • Photo by Ben Fisher
    Hedonism Wines, an exclusive shop in London's Mayfair district. Photo by Ben Fisher
  • Noteworthy single malts at Hedonism include bottle No. 1 of the 11-bottle release of the Glenfiddich Janet Sheed Roberts Reserve 55 Year Old.
  • Noteworthy single malts at Hedonism include a Laphroaig 14 Year Old from 1970 bottled for Osteria Apostoli in Milan.
  • Noteworthy single malts at Hedonism include the Balvenie Pure Malt 50 Year Old.
  • Photo by Marvin Shaouni
    Another "dusty" on offer at the Oakland Art Novelty Co. in Michigan: a bottle of Benedictine dating from the 1930s. Photo by Marvin Shaouni
  • Photo by Francesco Tonelli
  • Photo by Francesco Tonelli
  • Photo by Marvin Shaouni
  • Photo by Allen Lin
  • Photo by Ben Fisher
  • Photo by Ben Fisher
  • Photo by Marvin Shaouni

Originally published in the December issue of Robb Report Collection as “Willing Spirits

Thirsty collectors are on the hunt for long-lost libations—to save, sip, and sometimes even mix into a cocktail.

Like many of those leading today’s cocktail culture, Leo Robitschek has always been captivated by the history and folklore of classic mixed drinks and spirits. But for Robitschek—
the acclaimed director of NoMad Bar in New York City and author of the new NoMad Cocktail Book—the game-changing moment came when he actually tasted his first vintage Chartreuse. “In that first sip, I experienced how beautifully certain spirits age in the bottle,” he recalls, “and I knew this was something I would need to pursue further.”

Indeed, Robitschek now prowls auction catalogs and specialty liquor dealers in search of old and out-of-production bottles. He keeps his cache locked up (but in plain sight) in a cabinet at NoMad Bar. Peer inside, and you might find bottles of Campari from 1960 and 1970, when it was made with a different formula, as well as rare Chartreuse Tarragona from the 1960s, ’70s, and ’80s, a 1925 Navarre Cognac, a Glenglassaugh 37 Year Old single malt, and much, much more.

Curiosity might even prompt you to spend $175 for a pour of green Tarragona Chartreuse from the 1970s, or $138 for a shot of the 1977 Glenlivet 34 Year Old Samaroli single malt, just for the experience. “This is the first generation in a long time that has grown up with parents who are more adventurous drinkers,” Robitschek says. “They come by it honestly. In general, people are interested in better spirits and cocktails, just like they’re interested in better food and wine.”

Robitschek is at the forefront when it comes to the latest obsession of collectors and cocktail devotees: long-lost libations from elusive or vanished distilleries. These treasure hunters ardently pursue sealed bottles of almost everything—but especially bourbon, single-malt Scotch, rye, and Chartreuse—from years past. And not just the recent past (though gin and Scotch from the 1960s certainly got a boost thanks to Mad Men). The craft cocktail movement has resurrected classic mixed drinks from the last two centuries and a bedrock devotion to authenticity. After all, until Rob Cooper, president of the Cooper Spirits Co., discovered the recipe for a purple-hued Victorian liqueur called Crème Yvette a few years ago, mixologists could not have accurately re-created antique drinks like the Aviation, Stratosphere, Blue Moon, and Perpetual.

The greatest interest revolves around whiskeys and whiskies bearing labels and liquids that are no longer produced. At a sale conducted earlier this year by Zachys Wine Auctions, a bottle of Duncan Taylor Rare Auld Macallan 33 Year Old Single Malt Scotch 1969 sold for $1,960, while a bottle of the Macallan 18 Year Old Gran Reserva 1979 fetched $1,593. A year earlier, the auction house sold a bottle of A.H. Hirsch 16 Year Old Pennsylvania bourbon distilled in 1974 for a hammer price of $1,100. 

Derek Schreck, owner of Tom Bergin’s, a Los Angeles Irish pub that dates to 1936, saved the iconic establishment from demolition by purchasing it two years ago. As part of its renovation, he has transformed a clandestine upstairs area into Vestry, a speakeasy-style, members-only club stocked with such rarities as a bottle of Bonded Jim Beam from 1943, a 1968 bottle of Old Taylor, and a 1948 tax-stamp-dated bottle of Old Hickory 20 Year Old, a blended whiskey once produced by the now-defunct Publicker Commercial Alcohol Co. in Philadelphia (not the contemporary Old Hickory brand). Other vintage bourbons Schreck has procured for Vestry include Hill and Hill, Old Crow, Old Forester, and a 1973 Four Roses. These are only offered as shots, ranging from $40 to $300 a pour, depending upon the whiskey, or in flights, so that an entire range from various years can be experienced. 

“These are collectible whiskeys that I have on my ‘Once It’s Gone, It’s Gone’ list,” says Schreck. “So each Vestry customer gets a 1-ounce pour per bottle, per visit. Or they can purchase a flight, so if they wanted to taste Old Taylor from the ’40s, ’60s, ’80s, they can do that. But I don’t want someone with $2,000 coming in and buying an entire bottle. That way more Vestry members can experience these limited whiskeys.”

Individual collectors, of course, have the option—and the luxury—of enjoying bottles of their own. But that brings up the challenge of just how to source these vintage spirits. Schreck acquired his stock by selling, buying, and trading with other collectors, searching online forums such as lawhiskeysociety.com and methodically seeking out liquor stores in small towns.

“I drive into some of these towns in central California and stop into the older liquor stores,” he says. “For example, I know the bar code for National Distillers, and if you pull through their bottles to the back stock and find a bottle that still has the orange $2.99 price tag sticker on it, and you check the bar code, you can see that it was actually an old National Distillers bottle, such as Old Crow or Old Grand-Dad, and not a new Jim Beam bottle. 

“Sometimes you can still find these old bottles with their original price tags and the clerk will sell them to you for that price,” he continues. “That’s harder now, but it’s how a lot of the bigger collectors I’ve traded with had originally sourced their bottles. I’ve found a few bourbons like that once or twice, but now I usually end up trading with other collectors for bottles that they already have acquired.”

(Continues on next page...)

From Around the Web...
Slow sippers can put two bottles of wine on tap for up to 90 days…
The December 9th sale will showcase a variety of spirits, from whiskey to wine…
This blend for this 21-year-old single malt has been handpicked…
Bollinger uncovered a secret wine stash in its cellars…
Finished in Scotch casks, only 30 barrels of the 14-year-old expression exist…
From an 1891 sour mash to a pre-embargo Cuban Rum, each bygone bottle is sold through Soutirage…
Templeton Rye releases a special bottle to commemorate 10 years of being in business legally…
Connoisseurs who purchase a case of this Champagne will also receive a free trip to France…
The Loch Lomond region just might be the most under-sung capital of great Scotch…
The Macallan Double Cask 12 Years Old uses a blend of distillations and a surprising blend of casks...