Much like roasting, broiling is a simple cooking method that relies on high, direct heat from a standard kitchen oven. Meat, chicken, fish and vegetables can all be broiled to add flavor and texture, and to create healthier dishes with less fat and grease. Unlike roasting, however, the heat for broiling comes from the top of the oven—and you need a special pan to properly execute this technique.
Broiler pans are typically shallower than roasting pans and come with two separate pieces. The upper pan is where you place the food, and it features slots through which the drippings drain into the lower pan. Broiling pans are usually made of stainless steel or aluminum, though you can also find enameled and cast iron versions. Some versions feature non-stick coatings to help food release from the pan—and to make cleanup a little easier—while others feature angled slots that help grease drain more efficiently.
But regardless of your personal cooking style or specific culinary needs, you should be able to find a version whose features add value to your kitchen. Below, a selection of the best broiler pans available on Amazon.
1. Granite Ware Bake, Broil and Grill Pan Set
You’re not picking a broiler pan based on its appearance, but Granite Wear’s model sure is nice looking. The speckled porcelain enamel coating isn’t just for decoration, either, as it gives the pan a naturally non-stick surface. The brand’s pan features a carbon steel core that cooks evenly and browns better than the competition. But what really puts this excellent model over the top is the fact that you can use it for baking and broiling, too.
2. Range Kleen Broil and Bake Pan
Range Kleen’s two-piece set is crafted in steel covered with porcelain, making it a durable and heavy-duty option that’s also easy to clean (and dishwasher-safe.) Among the standout touches are angled grates on the top grill to help fat drain easily into the bottom broiler pan. Adding to the versatility, the bottom pan can also do double-duty as a baking dish and the top pan can be used on an outdoor grill. All of these elements help make this pick great for a range of foods, from meats to veggies.
3. General Electric Broiler Pan and Rack
Made by General Electric, this set is slightly larger than typical broiler pans, so it’s recommended to measure your oven to make sure it’s the best fit. The size makes is great for cooking steaks, ham, or whole chickens or fish. The non-stick finish is both easy on the food and easy to clean. The slotted top pan quickly lifts out, and the deep bottom pan safely catches the fat, resulting in healthier meals.
4. Farberware Bakeware Roaster with Flat Rack
Different from the typical broiler pans, this Farberware option features a wide, deep main pan topped by a flat, heavy-duty rack. Both sections are made of steel and a non-stick coating, making it easy to remove cooked food and to clean the pan. The chrome-plated broiler rack can be removed, allowing the deep main pan to be used on its own for baking. Given the size and design, this warp-resistant, two-handle option is ideal for cooking hearty proteins and side dishes, such as meat and potatoes, together.