The turkey is prepped and it’s time to make gravy. You have a roasting pan full of delicious juices that are sure to make a flavorful finished product, but there’s one major problem—that liquid gold is mixed in with a whole lot of excess fat. Though it adds considerable flavor, too much fat can prevent you from getting the results you want.
Now you could wait an eternity for it to cool and slowly spoon the fat off the top, but that’s cumbersome and time-consuming. This is the opportunity to break out a gravy separator.
Shaped almost like a measuring cup with a pronounced spout, these brilliant little vessels simultaneously strain the broth and effortlessly filter out unwanted fat. The nature of its design means that it’s a cinch to pour what remains into a separate pot or pan and complete any gravy, sauce or simply render a clear broth. These are our top four picks available on Amazon.
1. HIC Gravy Strainer
It never hurts when a useful kitchen tool also has a little style and HIC’s classic version has it in spades. Made from borosilicate glass that’s heat safe to 300 degrees Fahrenheit, it has a healthy four cup liquid capacity and detailed markings along the side so it doubles as a measuring cup. A removable steel lid—with an FDA-approved silicone seal—means this versatile piece also strains whatever goes inside. The narrow spout originates at the bottom of the vessel so you can pour out the flavorful broth, leaving the rendered fat neatly behind.
Pros: It comes with a convenient strainer lid.
Cons: The glass design might be more fragile than other materials.
2. Norpro Gravy Separator
When it comes to cooking, having a clear view of what you’re doing is essential and why this particular gravy separator is so good. Made from heat-resistant glass, you can pour turkey juices directly from the hot roasting pan to make gravy in a flash. If you’re worried about any large bits of food particulate or fond spoiling your sauce, don’t worry. This model has a removable lid with a built-in strainer to catch any unsightly bits that might result in a clumpy finished product.
Pros: The easy-to-hold handle design is comfortable even when the vessel is full.
Cons: This model doesn’t have measurement markings.
3. OXO Good Grips Gravy Separator
OXO Good Grips is always innovating so leave it to the trusty brand to reinvent a classic. While most models have a standard spout that originates from the bottom, this version eliminates that altogether instead opting for a trigger handle that releases the desired liquid directly from beneath. A built-in strainer in the lid catches unwanted bits and an external drain makes it a cinch to pour off the unwanted fat in the trash. Considering it also has numerous measurement markings, this is one of the most well thought through designs on this list.
Pros: Brilliant pour-from-the-bottom design.
Cons: Its thicker handle might be too large for some users.
4. Simax Glass Fat Separator
Sometimes you just need something that will get the job done well without any added bells and whistles. If that’s what you’re looking for in a gravy separator, you can’t beat Simax’s heat-resistant glass model. Designed with a standard 4-cup capacity, it has measurement markings along the side, but not too many so as to be difficult to interpret (no reading glasses required!). Its generous drip-free spout allows you to pour off liquid without worrying about any mess.
Pros: It has simple markings that are easy to read.
Cons: This model doesn’t come with a strainer lid.