Whether as a celebratory treat or as dessert after a big meal, most everyone loves a good pie. In fact, the dish is such a beloved staple in the states, that there’s the old saying “as American as apple pie.” It’s easy to make, too—if you have the right tools. Most importantly, you’ll need a good dough for the crust, a filling and a pie pan to hold it all together.
Despite the saying, apple pie wasn’t always so American. In fact, it was a culinary fixture for hundreds of years before making its way across the Atlantic. In medieval England, pies were “pyes,” and were filled with meat instead of sweets like apples or cherries. It wasn’t until the early 1800s when things like pumpkin pie were adopted in America. Regardless of which you prefer, you’ll need a pan that’s both durable and easy on the eyes, as you’ll often be taking the pie straight from the oven to the dinner table.
So, whether you prefer apple or a pumpkin pie, or even something a bit more savory, you’ll need a reliable pan to get the job done. Here are four of the best on Amazon.
1. Emile Henry Pie Dish
All of Emile Henry’s cookware is made by hand in France—its pie pan is crafted with Burgundy clay, so it has superior heat retention and diffusion properties. The ceramic glaze is extremely scratch resistant, so the dish won’t weather over time, and it can be used to make a myriad of different meals and desserts. Its high quality also means it can withstand temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, so it’s a suitably versatile instrument that you’ll want to have around the kitchen. And if you’d prefer a different hue, the pan comes in a handful of other color options.
2. Le Creuset Heritage Stoneware Pie Pan
Le Creuset is known for making stylish cookware that lasts, and its pie pan is no different. This stoneware dish is incredibly dense, so it will resist scratches and dents and can deal with temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. The high-quality materials also mean that the pan won’t easily absorb moisture, which can otherwise lead to cracking and rippling. Its a worthy tool that you’ll want to keep around, too, as it evenly distributes heat throughout the pie and retains heat so that it will stay warm during serving. And if red isn’t your thing, it comes in a range of other colors as well.
3. Homer Laughlin Ceramic Pie Dish
Homer Laughlin’s pie dish is green by hue and by nature. The company, which is America’s largest producer of dinnerware, says it implemented the latest green technologies to construct the ceramic design, which is colored just like lemongrass. The three-pound design is plenty durable, too. It can be placed in the microwave, oven or dishwasher without worry. It also features a hardwearing glaze to prevent any chipping. This is a fish that will stand the test of time and can be passed down from one generation to the next.
4. Wisenvoy Ceramic Pie Pan
If you’re someone who’s on the hunt for a more classic looking pie pan, look no further than Wisenvoy’s. The dish is adorned with hand-painted patterns and is made of a sturdy porcelain that will evenly distribute heat throughout. The edges are ridged and resemble a pie’s crust, though you needn’t always bake a pie in it—the pan is versatile enough to accommodate other foods as well. The downside? Because it’s made of porcelain, you may want to wash it by hand.