Quantcast
×

How to Tell if Your Keith Haring Is Fake, According to an Art Expert

Below, the telltale signs the artwork may have an authentication issue.

FILE - In this October 1986 file photo, artist Keith Haring stands in front of part of the Berlin Wall that he painted with a crawling baby in Berlin. The Berlin Wall came down in late 1989. Haring died of AIDS Feb. 16, 1990, at age 31.(AP Photo/Elke Bruhn-Hoffmann, File) Elke Bruhn-Hoffmann/AP

It’s hard to believe it’s been over 30 years since Keith Haring left us. Yet the impact of his career continues to reverberate beyond the art world. Witness Disney and Swatch’s recent collaboration with the artist’s estate to produce a new series of Mickey Mouse timepieces, and Dr. Martens’s release of a new collection of shoes embellished with Haring icons.

As for Haring’s art, most dealers and collectors would agree that it remains undervalued, especially when compared to his friends and colleagues Jean-Michel Basquiat and Andy Warhol.

Part of Haring’s enduring value is the life-affirming quality of his imagery, which brings something positive into our daily lives. This generosity of spirit informed his early “Subway Drawings,” which made the daily drudge of commuting just a little bit brighter.

What’s more, toward the end of his life, Haring grew to be very involved in the AIDS pandemic movement, often donating his work to related philanthropic causes.

However, all this notoriety came at a cost: Haring is one of the most forged artists of our time. His paintings and drawings are among the easiest to fake and hardest to authenticate. The reasons why are numerous.

Below are five telltale signs that the Haring you’re thinking of spending good money on may have an authentication issue. As always, when it comes to the world of art authentication, the rule of thumb is never to assume anything.

 

1. Always Look for a Continuous Line

Eine Besucherin schaut sich am 30.04.2015 die Ausstellung «Keith Haring - Gegen den Strich» in München (Bayern) an. Die überwiegend großformatigen Bilder und Objekte werden noch bis zum 30.08.2015 in der Kunsthalle der Hypo-Kulturstiftung zu sehen sein. Der Künstler gab den meisten seiner Werke keine Titel. Photo by: Peter Kneffel/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images

The exhibition ‘Keith Haring—The Political Line’ in Munich, Germany.  Peter Kneffel/AP

The genius of Haring is rooted in his draftsmanship. Most artists lay down a line in segments—but not Haring. He was blessed with the uncanny ability to draw his subject, whether simple or complex, with a continuous unbroken line.

This characteristic almost always thwarts counterfeiters when they attempt to reproduce his work. Always be on the lookout for paintings and drawings, reputed to be by Haring, with a hesitant line marked by fits and starts.

 

2. Avoid Drawings With Dominant Signatures

Keith Haring work at BOZAR museum in Brussels

Keith Haring work at BOZAR museum in Brussels.  Francisco Seco/AP

Many of the fake Haring drawings on the market tend to be of modest scale. Yet they often include signatures as a dominant element in the composition.

While Haring was never shy about signing his works, he did so in a way that never detracted from the main imagery. In other words, his name was there for all to see, but your eyes went to the subject first. Numerous forgeries are distinguished by signatures that catch your attention before you move on to the imagery.

 

3. Pay Attention to the Condition of the “Subway Drawings”

Museum employees stands in front of works by US-American artist Keith Haring at the Museum for Art and Trade ('Museum fuer Kunst und Gewerbe', MfKG) in Hamburg, Germany, 29 May 2017. The exhibition 'Keith Haring. Posters.' can be seen from 31 May until 5 November 2017. Photo by: Christian Charisius/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images

The exhibition ‘Keith Haring. Posters.’ at at the Museum for Art and Trade in Germany.  Christian Charisius/AP

From 1980 to 1985, Haring produced between 2,000 and 3,000 “Subway Drawings.” Perhaps 5 to 10 percent survived. Technically, every genuine example was stolen from the walls of New York’s subways.

The problem is, fake examples are created with the same “weathered” qualities as those that are authentic. When a glued down “Subway Drawing” was quickly removed from its advertising panel, it often tore the edges of the black construction paper.

Be wary of those drawings where the tears are too symmetrical. Also, the backs of genuine “Subway Drawings” are generally covered with remnants of previous advertising posters, which are often layered. Forgers are on to this, and have figured out how to reproduce this effect.

 

4. Beware of Crawling Babies and Barking Dogs

Atmosphere - March 14, 2012 - The Brooklyn Museum Hosts a Dinner Celebrating the Opening of the Special Exhibition KEITH HARING: 1978-1982 held at The Brooklyn Museum, NYC. Photo Credit: Ryan Mccune/PatrickMcMullan.com/Sipa USA

The exhibition ‘Keith Haring: 1978-1982’ at The Brooklyn Museum, NYC.  Patrick McMullan Co./AP

Just as golden crowns became closely associated with Jean-Michel Basquiat, so did crawling babies and barking dogs with Haring.

A plethora of the two icons appear on many Haring forgeries. Be particularly careful with objects—especially enamel street and subway signs, old wooden doors, orange-striped street barricades, and subway tiles—that feature one or both of these images. The same holds true for alleged quick sketch “gifts” on paper from the artist.

 

5. Watch Out for Gifts to Boyfriends

Visitors look around the exhibition 'Keith Haring - The Political Line' in Munich, Germany, 30 April 2015. The mostly large-format pictures and objects can be seen in the Kunsthalle of the Hypo-Cultural Foundation until 30 August 2015. The artist left most of his work untitled. Photo by: Peter Kneffel/picture-alliance/dpa/AP Images

The exhibition ‘Keith Haring—The Political Line’ in Munich, Germany.  Peter Kneffel/AP

Speaking of gifts, perhaps the biggest problem with fake Harings lies within the realm of major and minor canvases, both stretched and unstretched, that come with extensive backstories about how Keith gave them to an old boyfriend.

They are usually accompanied by an elaborate provenance that’s hard to trace. One of the giveaways is that the boyfriend has usually passed away, making the story almost impossible to confirm.

When it comes to authenticating a questionable Haring painting, always make sure the provenance can be verified. (And be wary of signed “legal” declarations by the owner!)

Richard Polsky is the owner of Richard Polsky Art Authentication, which specializes in authenticating the work of seven artists: Andy Warhol, Jean-Michel Basquiat, Keith Haring, Roy Lichtenstein, Jackson Pollock, Georgia O’Keeffe, and Bill Traylor.

More stories from Artnet News: 

 

Read More On:

More Art & Collectibles